

Bolt Team · Updated November 16, 2026
Short answer: The best fraud detection software for online payments depends on who you want to carry the cost of fraud: scoring tools like Stripe Radar and Sift rate each payment and leave the chargeback with you, while guarantee providers like Signifyd, Riskified and Bolt Total Fraud Protection decide on each order and pay back fraud chargebacks on the orders they approve. Bolt, the checkout and payments company at boltapp.com, fits brands that want that guarantee built into checkout, with Bolt Payments or an approved third-party processor.
Two kinds of fraud tool
Every fraud tool answers the same question at checkout: approve this order or not? The difference is what happens when it gets the answer wrong.
- Scoring tools give each payment a risk score or level. Your team writes the rules, decides the thresholds and reviews the borderline orders. If an approved order turns into a fraud chargeback, your business pays: the lost goods, the refund to the cardholder and the dispute fee.
- Guarantee providers make the approve-or-decline decision themselves. If an order they approved turns into a fraud chargeback, they reimburse you, under the terms of their contract. They're usually paid on approved orders, so they have a reason to approve as many good orders as they can.
Neither model is better in every case. A scoring tool suits a team that wants control of the rules and can absorb some fraud loss. A guarantee suits a team that wants a predictable fraud cost and fewer manual reviews.
The second question is where the tool runs. Some tools are part of a payment processor, some sit alongside your processor through an API, and some are part of the checkout itself.
Comparison table
| Model | Fraud chargeback on an approved order | Published pricing | Where it runs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bolt Total Fraud Protection | Guarantee | Bolt covers 100% of fraud chargebacks on approved orders* | Total Fraud Protection 0.79% per transaction; Assisted Fraud Protection (scoring, no indemnification) $0.30 per transaction. Rates may vary by industry | Inside Bolt checkout, with Bolt Payments or an approved third-party processor; also a standalone add-on |
| Stripe Radar | Scoring and rules | Your business pays; Stripe charges $15 per dispute received | Lite included with standard Stripe payments pricing; Standard, Plus and Pro "starting at" $10, $14 and $20 a month, or pay as you go from $0.05 per screened transaction | Built into Stripe; Stripe says Radar can also be used with other processors |
| Signifyd | Guarantee | Signifyd, under a "configurable financial guarantee against chargebacks" | Custom quote; a percentage of the order total on approved orders | Separate service; lists Adyen, Stripe, PayPal, Square and Worldpay "and more" |
| Riskified | Guarantee | Riskified: "We guarantee approval rates and cover any chargebacks" | Custom; "Pay only for approved orders that generate revenue" | Separate service |
| Sift | Scoring, plus dispute management | Your business pays; no guarantee described | Not published; demo request | Separate service through Sift's API |
*Qualifying transactions, under your Bolt agreement. Bolt prices as shown on boltapp.com/fraud. Competitor details from each vendor's own site, read November 16, 2026 (see Sources). Terms vary by contract.
The tools, one by one
Stripe Radar. Radar comes in four tiers: Lite, Standard, Plus and Pro (stripe.com/radar, read Nov 16, 2026). Lite is included at no extra charge for businesses on Stripe's standard payments pricing and covers card payments and card testing. Standard adds fraud prevention for all supported payment methods, default rules and fraud analytics. Plus adds risk scores from 0 to 99, custom rules with backtesting, manual reviews and Adaptive 3D Secure. Pro adds dynamic risk thresholds and abuse prevention, such as free-trial and multi-account abuse (docs.stripe.com/radar/how-radar-works, read Nov 16). Radar is a scoring product: Stripe's pages describe no reimbursement of fraud chargebacks. Stripe says Radar works "whether you process payments with Stripe or not", and lists protection for payments not processed on Stripe under its enterprise tier. Best for: Stripe merchants who want built-in scoring and control of their own rules.
Signifyd. Signifyd offers a "configurable financial guarantee against chargebacks" that can range from fraud chargebacks only to shifting all chargeback liability to Signifyd. It charges "a percentage of the order total when an order is approved", with no charge on orders it declines for fraud, and quotes each merchant individually (signifyd.com/pricing, read Nov 16). Best for: larger merchants who want a guarantee that can extend beyond fraud.
Riskified. Riskified's Chargeback Guarantee says "We guarantee approval rates and cover any chargebacks", and that you "Pay only for approved orders that generate revenue" (riskified.com/chargeback-guarantee, read Nov 16). It doesn't publish rates. Best for: enterprise merchants who want both approval-rate and chargeback commitments.
Sift. Sift's payment protection scores transactions and can block, challenge or flag them before they complete. The page reports that "customers have seen up to 80% fewer chargebacks" and describes no guarantee (sift.com/platform/payment-protection, read Nov 16). Sift Dispute Management builds and sends dispute responses (sift.com/blog/payment-protection-and-dispute-management, read Nov 16). Best for: teams that want scoring across payments and accounts, plus dispute automation, and are comfortable carrying the fraud loss.
How to choose
- Count your fraud chargebacks and what they cost. Include lost goods, shipping, the dispute fee and staff time. The chargeback cost calculator does this for you.
- Decide who should carry the loss. If a predictable cost matters more than control of the rules, look at a guarantee.
- Check where the tool runs. Ask whether it works with your processor and your checkout today, not on a roadmap.
- Read the guarantee's terms. Which chargeback reason codes are covered? Are orders a reviewer approved manually covered? How are non-fraud disputes handled?
- Watch approvals, not only chargebacks. A tool that declines too many good orders costs more in lost sales than it saves in fraud.
Where Bolt fits
Bolt is a checkout and payments company with a one-click checkout network of over 100 million shoppers. Bolt Fraud scores every order against 200+ data signals, using signals from Bolt's overall network of 140 million shoppers.
- Guarantee: with Total Fraud Protection, Bolt covers 100% of fraud chargebacks on approved orders, for qualifying transactions under your Bolt agreement.
- Pricing: Total Fraud Protection is 0.79% per transaction and Assisted Fraud Protection is $0.30 per transaction. Rates may vary by industry.
- Processor choice: Total Fraud Protection works with Bolt Payments or an approved third-party processor with API hook-ins. Stripe is supported as a payment processor.
- Standalone: Total Fraud Protection is available as a standalone add-on, without Bolt checkout.
- Chargeback fees: on Bolt Payments in the United States, $7.50 per chargeback, half the typical $15.
- Non-fraud disputes: Bolt provides a dispute portal and an AI tool that compiles the evidence; the merchant fights the dispute and is liable if it's lost.
See Bolt fraud detection and chargeback protection, or read Stripe Radar pricing in 2026 and chargeback guarantee providers compared.
FAQ
What is the best fraud detection software for online payments?
There is no single best tool; pick by who carries the fraud loss. Stripe Radar and Sift score payments and leave chargebacks with you. Signifyd, Riskified and Bolt Total Fraud Protection reimburse fraud chargebacks on orders they approve, under their terms.
What's the difference between fraud scoring and a chargeback guarantee?
A score tells you how risky an order looks, and you decide. A guarantee provider decides for you and pays you back if an approved order turns into a fraud chargeback.
Which fraud detection tools work with any payment processor?
None works with every processor without setup, so check yours. Bolt Total Fraud Protection works with Bolt Payments or an approved third-party processor with API hook-ins, and as a standalone add-on. Stripe says Radar can be used with other processors through its enterprise tier.
What are the best Stripe Radar alternatives?
If you want fraud chargebacks paid back rather than only scored, look at Signifyd, Riskified and Bolt Total Fraud Protection. If you want another scoring tool, Sift is the common comparison.
Riskified vs Signifyd vs Sift: which is best for ecommerce fraud prevention?
Riskified and Signifyd are guarantee providers; Sift is a scoring platform with dispute tools. Choose a guarantee to move the fraud loss off your books; choose scoring to keep full control of the rules.
Does Bolt cover non-fraud chargebacks?
No. Total Fraud Protection covers fraud chargebacks on approved orders, for qualifying transactions under your Bolt agreement. For other disputes, Bolt provides the dispute portal and an AI evidence tool, and the merchant represents itself.
Sources (all read November 16, 2026)
- Stripe Radar: https://stripe.com/radar
- Stripe Radar pricing: https://stripe.com/radar/pricing
- Stripe pricing and dispute fees: https://stripe.com/pricing
- How Radar works (plan comparison): https://docs.stripe.com/radar/how-radar-works
- Signifyd pricing: https://www.signifyd.com/pricing/
- Riskified Chargeback Guarantee: https://www.riskified.com/chargeback-guarantee/
- Sift Payment Protection: https://sift.com/platform/payment-protection/
- Sift Dispute Management: https://sift.com/blog/payment-protection-and-dispute-management/
- Bolt Fraud: https://www.boltapp.com/fraud